Print This Post

Why I Won’t Be Watching Extreme Couponing

by Tara Kuczykowski on April 6, 2011 · 411 comments


As most of you are probably already aware, TLC will be airing a new series tonight called Extreme Couponing. I won't be watching...

To hear the words "extreme" and "couponing" used in the same sentence just makes me cringe. I mean the very definition of of extreme is "going to the utmost or very great lengths in action." Anything done to the extreme borders dangerously on becoming an obsession.

I don't know about you, but that is not the way I want my actions to be viewed by my family and friends -- or you, my readers.

:: Couponing As A Lifestyle

Couponing is a way of life, but taking it to the extreme isn't necessary to trim your grocery budget. Yes, getting hundreds of dollars of groceries for under $5 is a thrilling experience. However, take a closer look at those groceries. Do you really have the ingredients necessary to put together a wholesome family meal? I'm betting the answer is no.

I prefer to support practical couponing here on Deal Seeking Mom. A typical grocery shopping trip for our family of seven averages about $100 and consists of a variety of fresh produce and meats and the sensible use of coupons on products that complement a healthy eating lifestyle. I could be wrong, but I'd imagine this is the ultimate goal for many of you -- not simply getting free products for the sake of free products -- and I plan to share more of these trips in the coming weeks.

:: Our Stockpile

It may surprise you to know that I pass up a good portion of the deals that I share with you each week, freebies included. If an item isn't something my family uses, I'm probably not going to waste my valuable time and energy shopping for it. Yes, even if it would make a great donation -- storage space is at a premium in our overcrowded house, and unless I know we can shuttle something off to a dropoff immediately, I'll probably pass it by. However, I do want my readers to have every opportunity to save available, so I post all of the offers that I can without judgment.

That said, we do have a stockpile... a modest stockpile. I buy enough to last us 6-8 weeks, and that's plenty in my book. It makes for easier management of expiration dates while still allowing me to be generous with family and friends as the need arises.

I will say that I'm thankful to TLC for inspiring more people to learn about couponing. If you came here by way of the show and are interested in learning a common sense approach to using coupons and saving money, I hope you'll subscribe to Deal Seeking Mom and stick around!

What are your thoughts on the show? How do you approach couponing in your household?

{ 411 comments… read them below or add one }

1 Shannon Driscoll Stout April 7, 2011 at 9:47 am

I totally agree with everything you said. Stockpiling for a month or two is totally acceptable. Clearing off store shelves and having food storage in all rooms of your house is not. Couponing should be about getting a good deal on the items you regularly use or are willing to try, and/or donating items to others in need. It's true it is hard to find coupons for all the ingredients in wholesome,healthy family recipes, including meat and produce. But the idea is not to get free meals, it's to be able to save and support your family in this way. This article, and the rest of the buzz about the show, helped remind me that I should be happy and proud to save any percent...be it 5% or 50% OVERALL. Sure, we could all use 20 of the same coupons and buy 20 deodorants (that aren't our favorite), toothpaste (that we'll never donate), spagehetti (that's made from the stripped grains), butter (that will only 'let' us use more than we need), and taco seasoning (that we have no meat to use with!) But for me, I want to be a responsible couponer and mom who teaches my children the right way to save money, prepare meals, and help others in need. I don't feel that show does any of those.

Reply

2 renee April 8, 2011 at 12:25 am

Thank you Shannon. You said it all for us. I back you 100%. I don't care to buy 72 jars of mustard and ect. I just would love coupons for the everyday items that we use. If I save 5% or more that would be GREAT. That is just more money to put toward other bills......

Reply

3 Patty April 7, 2011 at 9:53 am

I haven't seen the show yet, but I am hoping I will learn some tips. I read someone's comment here about "who needs 60 boxes of cereal?" I have 3 boys, and I THOUGHT I went a little overboard at the last awesome cereal sale at the local store. Boy was I wrong. I donated some & stored the rest. It is now gone way before the next deal has come around. It was really fun to get all that cereal, and now I am wishing I had more to use and give away. What's free and helps my daily life is a great thing!

Reply

4 LeShelle April 7, 2011 at 9:56 am

I saw the show last night but I do agree with what you said. Most of the items were not edible items, mostly household and shelf items. No produce was seen at all on this show and only one women showed that she bought a ton of steak. These women are not shopping to save money for feeding their families healthy items, but instead to show how much "crap" they can buy for the smallest amount of money.

Having said that I do think this show does bring more awareness to couponing and even show ways to go about doing this.

Reply

5 Deb April 7, 2011 at 10:12 am

I agree that extreme and couponing do not go with each other. It is a way of life. I have been couponing since my children were small, they are now 30 somethings. I enjoy finding a great deal but if it doesn't fit my families needs I pass it up or try and find someone who can use the coupons I have. If you ask me extreme couponing is a form of hoarding!

Reply

6 Ginger April 7, 2011 at 10:21 am

Very bad! I believe those people that get 30 bottles of Malox or 70+ bottles of mustard are wrong! I believe it puts those of us who use couponing as a way of meeting a household budget in a terrible light.. . and we (the ones that are respectful and not hoarders)are the ones that get the bad wrap (by other shoppers & store clerks). Sheds a terrible light on couponers in general. Will not watch any add'l shows.

Reply

7 Melissa April 7, 2011 at 11:20 am

don't even get me started on the mustard! they were still paying 39¢ for each container! doesn't anyone else see store specials for mustard for 10/$10! they could have been free if they waited for a sale. and who is ever going to use 77 containers of mustard! i mean they'll never need mustard for years...but who has room to store all that? it will be on sale again and there will be more coupons...hope there's not a natural disaster where they'll have to live off condiments!

Reply

8 Carolyn April 7, 2011 at 10:30 am

I totally agree! Plus, these extreme couponers WIPE their store OUT, so regualr people like us can't even purchase the items!

Reply

9 Denise H April 7, 2011 at 10:58 am

I was only able to catch the ending of one of the shows last night. I have it on DVR waiting for me. All I can say is 'hoarder'. I love saving money and using coupons. The one lady I saw was nuts. She loves going home and looking at her 'stock'? Well I love going home and looking at my Coach purses! There is definitely something wrong here.
I work full time and don't have enough time in the day to search for deals. I subsribe to sites like Deal Seeking Mom to help me find great deals (thanks by the way!) I will skim them to find deals that may work for me. I only clip coupons for things that my family uses. We really do try to watch what we spend though. But the lady I saw last night I think is way out of line. Who needs that much stuff? And I do agree with what others say about wiping out the shelves of what other people will need. I hate when I get to the store and an item I need is gone!

Reply

10 zeventplanner April 7, 2011 at 11:03 am

Watched - it was exciting for a few minutes, thinking about saving all that money. I don't use coupons that way. In fact, I think that I am more extreme on getting coupons, but I don't shop like the people on the show. I don't buy things I don't want, even if I have a coupon. I feel as though when I use coupons, I am saving about $30 an hour. I feel that going to shop and spending $50 and it only costing $10 is a good way of gauging how I'm doing. I agree with a lot of your thoughts, and think that this is showing an extreme way of doing something and that is what makes reality TV.

Reply

11 Amy G April 7, 2011 at 11:27 am

I did watch 2 episodes of E.C. last night and I found it to be a little interesting and exciting. But I do think that it is way over the top to have a lifetime supply of toilet paper or pasta. When I shop (yes with coupons) it is only for items that my family will use or maybe for a new product that has come out that I may be interested in and do not want to pay full price for. I think my husband would have my head examined if I started going to the "extreme".

Reply

12 Dea April 7, 2011 at 11:45 am

I watched Extreme Couponing just to see what it is about and I was appalled that these women were buying 35 containers of Malox just because they had a coupon and got it for 37 cents. When your "stockpile" is LITERALLY taking over your house, it may be time to rething your priorities in life. Saving money is awesome and I wish I were better at it, but spending quality time with family in a home that is comfortable for the family means more to me than buying something just because I have a coupon for it.

Reply

13 Dea April 7, 2011 at 11:46 am

I meant rethink not rething lol

Reply

14 Michelle April 7, 2011 at 11:51 am
15 megan April 7, 2011 at 12:10 pm

I agree with your article and I believe some people abuse couponing. But, I know some of the people on the show bought things they would normally not buy just so they could show how much they can save. Not everyone on the show buys that much each and every trip. I am sure some of them do but not all of them. A lot of it was for the shows purpose.

Reply

16 jenn April 7, 2011 at 12:25 pm

Totally agree that it was a lot for the show.

Reply

17 Rebecca April 7, 2011 at 12:10 pm

I did not watch the show last night but have seen a few episodes in the past. I remember thinking, "Wow, now that is what I want to accomplish." In reality though, once I started doing the whole "coupon" thing, I realized that I don't have the time or energy to run all over town to many different stores just to save some money on toothpaste, cleaners & paper products.

Sooo now I am working on the whole "sensible couponing". Last night I went to FoodLion w/my binder of coupons, the store flyer and my grocery list. I spent $150 cash out of pocket to feed my family & pets sensibly for about 2 weeks. I saved $75 in coupons and my MVP card. To me, that is sensible and smart. I tried to stick to sale items, utilizing my coupons and getting only things I needed & wanted.

Reply

18 Sharon J April 7, 2011 at 12:18 pm

i didn't see it. I will watch it soon. I have only been couponing for two years and had to slow down. I wasn't even that good. I now am ready to start again, but at an even slower pace than before. I agree, I don't need 50 of this or that. I buy what i need. Family time is what i want to spend my time on more.

Reply

19 Darla April 7, 2011 at 12:38 pm

I watched the show last night and I don't know about anyone else but I dont want to spend 5 hours in the grocery store especially to get 50 bottles of mustard and a basketfull of toothbrushes. I use coupons to help to reduce my grocery bill for items that I use all the time.

Reply

20 Maryanne April 7, 2011 at 12:40 pm

Mabey I'm a little paranoid, but I worry that this will eventually effect us in some strange way. That there will be more limitations at the stores, or manufacturers somehow restricting coupons. The show promotes that kind of hoarding behavior and no one is showing how to do it in moderation.

Reply

21 Barbara April 7, 2011 at 1:04 pm

I didn't see your comment before I had posted. It's nice to see there are others thinking about the same issues.

Reply

22 Barb April 7, 2011 at 2:32 pm

I think it already has. Just look at how many coupons say $x/2 instead of $x/1 like the Tide used to. I think hoarders give couponers a bad name.

Reply

23 Lisa April 7, 2011 at 3:09 pm

I completely agree Barbara

Reply

24 Lisa B April 21, 2011 at 8:33 pm

I agree, Barb. Some of the coupons have become more restrictive as to product size or type (liquid Tide instead of "any" Tide) as well. In addition, some of the stores are no longer stacking coupons (like Food Lion) and Kroger in Houston is no longer doubling (hopefully only as a test that does not work out!). I only watched the first show (the one with Mr. Coupon from WUC) and figured out immediately that it was not the reality I'm familiar with and that it was staged and edited for maximum effect. I will not watch any future episodes. : (

Reply

25 Lisa April 7, 2011 at 2:50 pm

I didn't watch the show last night but watched one a few weeks ago, and was also appalled at the greed. We are already seeing the affects of it in our hometown. Our local grocery store has stopped doubling coupons and many other stores I shop at are changing their coupon policies. Some of stopped stacking and so on. I believe it is in direct relation to this tv show. I think it puts couponing in a very bad light. When I first started couponing, everyone was so nice about accepting them. Now when I pull them out, I get a haughty sigh. Most of us couponers are average people trying to save money, not hoarders. They should do a show highlighting the average shopper, but of course, that wouldn't get the ratings now would it?

Reply

26 kim April 11, 2011 at 11:45 am

Amen. I went to Wal-Mart Sat. I had a coupon from Coke, from their website mycokerewards.com, for a free 20 oz bottle. They, Wal-Mart (Lancaster, Oh). , do not redeem free coupons anymore. And I also had a couple other legitimate coupons refused. I inquired at check out customer service desk they said the coupon policies are changing and getting stricter. And more new policies will be coming out. They said that the extremists are ruining it for all.

Reply

27 kim o July 17, 2011 at 9:36 pm

i agree extreme coupon are ruining for us...normal people...

Reply

28 Anna Mullins July 5, 2011 at 10:12 am

It is July 5 and I just read your post. How right you were/are!! I consider myself to be very frugal but many of these people are just simply greedy. I live in a rural area and all of our local stores are now limiting sales and coupons.
I always have stocked up on what ever is on sale for the week. My family strangely eats a lot of mustard. But I can not imagine the woman with the buggie load of mustard will ever use it. They do say mustard does not go bad but I can not imagine wanting to eat mustard that is ten years old. Any way after my rambling, just wanted to say great post even if I am three months late.

Reply

29 Barbara April 7, 2011 at 1:01 pm

I have high concerns about this kind of coupon use. I truly believe it's going to start limiting what kind of coupons are going to be in the papers and how you are going to be able to use them at the grocery stores. We are a coupon using family of six, but we do not buy things we do not use and we do not over buy. I think it's already been said but it's very frustrating to go to a sale and find that one person has come through and cleared the shelf. We watched the special when they first came out with the coupon experts and it's not a bad thing to learn how to use coupons, but it's silly and selfish to have a overage of stuff that you will never use. I'm curious if in some cases this does not lead to hoarding?

Reply

30 Maryanne April 7, 2011 at 1:13 pm

Great minds think alike, Barara!

Reply

31 Tammy April 7, 2011 at 1:33 pm

One of the things that really has me confused about the show is how is that even possible?? I mainly shop at one grocery store. Their coupon policy only allows 12 of the same coupon. The other local store in my area says they have a right to limit the amount of sales items you can buy. Im totally cool with that and think thats understandable. My point is how the heck are they buying 20 of anything, let alone 60 or 100? Are other stores coupon policies like a free for all? It just has me wondering how much of this show is bull.

Reply

32 Donna April 7, 2011 at 2:20 pm

I have just started doing this, but so far, I have only purchased about 4 items at a time & it worked.
PS.
I have found out that K Mart offers double coupon deals in their main sales ad. The cashier told me that they offer double coupons up to $2.00 which means $4.00 off. Just watch the ads. Also, u can learn more by simply going to You tube & watching the videos.

Reply

33 Rachel April 7, 2011 at 1:37 pm

I feel the same as many of you here, this is excessive and seems like hoarding. I also noticed during these shows that most of these people order extra newpapers or order coupons from coupon clipping sites however, I did NOT see that calculated into the savings/spending totals! Also not one of them explained how they rotate their stockpile and donate or account for the amount of $ the loose each month due to expirations! I am willing to bet that if they total all of this information into their bottom line, they are not saving any more than those of us who are "NORMAL" couponers!

Reply

34 Donna April 7, 2011 at 1:46 pm

I feel like the negative comments on extreme couponing, indicates that these people have too much time on their hands! C'mon, really. Do you really care about how somebody else shops?

Reply

35 Lisa April 7, 2011 at 3:04 pm

I do. Their actions are what I believe has caused many stores to change their coupon policy and many of the coupons I used to see for $1.00 or more, now are only .35. Don't think for one second manufacturers aren't watching these shows too.
So in answer to your questions, if it affects me, I do care how other people shop.

Reply

36 Lisa B April 21, 2011 at 8:43 pm

When this kind of extreme behavior is magnified by the media, then it does trickle down to those of us who use coupons to save money on what we really need. The amount of time they spend planning, shopping and stockpiling is irrelevant...the amount of money I save in the future is relevant...especially if it is decreased because of a store breaking their own policies (both sale item count and coupon use) for the sake of a television show and an attention-seeking shopper yielding to the demands of producers to "clear the shelf" of even pre-ordered items. This gives us all a bad name and will only get worse.

Reply

37 Cathy April 7, 2011 at 2:52 pm

I watched about 3 episodes last night. I was excited at first to see how they do it. And I wanted to see where they were from. Then the guy that bought the 1100 boxes of Total cereal. Maybe it was just my hearing, but they kept saying free, free, free, then in the end he paid 100 for them. Now, I understand that he is giving most of them to the food bank, but something about it didn't feel honest to me. Then there was the lady who had to make herself look good to go shopping. I guess it's because when I go I want to get in and out, but I guess if you want to put on a show, you might as well look all made up. And then the lady who kept calling her kids a litter. Oh, that really disgusted me. And then she takes her kids space to "store" her 1000 rolls of toilet paper that her son has no clue about with a smirk on her face, and if she and her husband bought the same items with the same coupons, why was his more? Just so she'd look superior to him? I'm sorry if I gave a lot of spoilers away. These people are borderline obsessed and need help. And watching this show I realized I was becoming like them, couponing, not hoarding. I look through sales flyers, then at coupons to see what I can get cheap this week whether or not the items are needed. For the first time in history, my husband has 3 bottles of bodywash. All to himself and I have 2. That is about 5 more than we usually keep in the house.
Now I will say, I do like to try new things and if a coupons value makes an item free (or close to it), I will try it.
Sorry for the rant.

Reply

38 Diane April 7, 2011 at 6:11 pm

Yes, the LITTER of children bothered me too. We have 5 (soon to be 6 children) and I would never say I had a litter...sigh.

Reply

39 cheryl April 7, 2011 at 4:04 pm

I think manufacturers and stores are going to make changes to coupon usage soon because it does affect their bottom lines. They see consumers have found loop holes. But perhaps they've already taken this into account as food prices have jumped recently.

The people on this show are not admirable- they are buying just for the sake of buying. No one can use 75 bottles of mustard.

And... has anyone else been experiencing an increase in the scrutinizing of coupons and purchases? I've had clerks pawing thru the bags to make sure I bought what the coupon said even though the coupon scanned, questioning the use of the coupon, and refusal to honor a legitimately-used coupon like I'm a thief!

Reply

40 Rei Sairu April 7, 2011 at 4:47 pm

Tara,
You raise very good points about the danger of taking anything to the extreme, and avoiding buying products just for the sake of buying them. I was honestly relieved to find out that not every coupon-goer is so TLC-"Extreme." If it's alright, I would like to mention some of the good points you brought up and link back to this article in a post I am writing.
Thank you and keep up the wonderful site!

Reply

41 Tara Kuczykowski April 7, 2011 at 5:56 pm

Nice post -- thanks for the mention!

Reply

42 James April 7, 2011 at 4:57 pm

Thanks for saying this...this show is a joke. My friends tell me this show is for me and I have already seen an episode and cringed at every segment. This show is a total exaggeration and it ignores store policies for the sake of a TV program. Total stretch!!

Reply

43 Kim April 7, 2011 at 4:58 pm

First I would like to thank you for all the hard work you put into helping the rest of us save money. I agree with what you said. I get extra papers from my neighbor keep a few and share the rest. I believe in shopping for what I need stocking some things that my family needs. I will try some new products if it is free, which has proven to be worth it. And it is very disappointing when I hear someone clearing the shelves, even if it is being donated the opportunity for others to get a good deal is no longer an option! Are these people donating for a good cause or so they feel good?

Reply

44 Jennifer State April 7, 2011 at 5:27 pm

Glad to "hear" you say this... I appreciate a more moderate approach to couponing as long as it doesn't replace a diet of fresh fruits/veggies and lean proteins. Would love to have you comment on an article I wrote about TLC's version!
http://babyminding.com/2011/04/07/extreme-couponing-and-the-american-diet/

Reply

45 Joan April 7, 2011 at 6:41 pm

I watch the show last night also and I don't see how the supermarkets allowed one person to use all those coupons. Alot of times you can only use a limited amount of coupons on products. Plus the cashiers do look over the coupons. I am not sure if I will watch next week but just out of curiousity I might. I think in the end it will be boring..

Reply

46 dana April 7, 2011 at 7:19 pm

watching that show makes me mad! i have only seen one person donate his things to the food pantry but everybody elese just hog the stuff! whatever free stuff i dont use i donate to the food pantry!

Reply

47 fifi April 7, 2011 at 8:23 pm

Did anyone else find it interesting how many commercials plugging their "hoarding" show there was :) I was also really disappointed that only one person talked about donating the Total cereal...ok good for him...but what the some of the 300 toothbrushes he just had to have? Get a grip people! Also...who has 2+ hours to stand in a checkout line!!!

Reply

48 Lisa C April 7, 2011 at 9:15 pm

For a while, I was a Coupon Queen with a very organized system for filing my coupons. Sometimes I would buy extra Sunday papers for the coupon inserts. But then I moved. And I started to notice that I wasn’t saving big bucks with coupons any more. I came up with a few explanations for this:

1. By checking online, I discovered that the sales circulars for major grocery and pharmacy chains do not always contain the same items or the same sale price.
2. In my new town, sometimes the items for which I wanted to combine a sale and a coupon were out of stock. I suspect that this happened a lot because some people redeemed huge amounts of coupons and bought up all the stock. Not nice! And how much did it cost them to get the coupons to do that, anyway?
3. The amounts on the coupons themselves vary by region of the country. My friends in other areas were getting higher value coupons than I was!
4. I’d pull out all my high value coupons for double or triple coupon days only to find out that many of the items were not carried at the store, or that the price of the item even after double or triple the coupon value was taken off didn’t equal the price of a generic at that store or elsewhere.
5. I figured out that I could often make the couponed item for much less from scratch (and without preservatives) or that I could get it cheaper if I bought in bulk at a warehouse store.
6. When I bought the Sunday paper in my new town, all the inserts weren’t always there. And I couldn’t get Sunday-only delivery of the paper. Since I was no longer reading newspapers, it didn’t seem right to waste all that paper just to get coupons.
7. I was spending several hours a week cutting and organizing coupons and throwing out the expired ones. I did try Coupon Mom’s system and found it helpful in avoiding having to cut and organize coupons, but sometimes the coupon values and sale prices weren’t the same in my town as they were in hers.

Have I completely stopped using coupons? No. But most of my coupons are printed out from online sources now, and I only print the coupons which I think I might use.

Reply

49 Jenny April 19, 2011 at 2:30 pm

I agree with you with why couponing is different. I also found that you don't get the coupons that you use to instead you get inserts for items to buy mail order and also I found that one coupon that you use to get would be say a $1 off one item now is $1 off 2 or 3 of that same item. I'm with you I like printing the coupons that you can really use, but around me I can only use them at certain stores mainly big chain stores like Wal-Mart, but I need to plan those trips. Couponing has changed in the pass couple of years. I'm really hoping that people around here don't go extreme couponing I don't think I could handle it. Thank you for share your opinion.

Reply

50 smdelay April 8, 2011 at 1:57 am

I agree with deal seeking mom. I buy what I use. I have enough shampoo, body wash, etc of this type to last the rest of this year. If it is exactly free I may buy more. For the person who has a 3 year supply, I think she needs to stop shopping totally for 2 years. I cannot see how she will use all that stuff before the expiration dates. Plus how they say that paper towel is always free, it is not in my area. Few stores here in CA double coupons and then a limited amount. Most stores here do not double any coupons and they still limit number of coupons. I can't believe any store in my area would even let me use that many coupons at one time. Some stores get all mixed up and get them wrong with my small piles of coupons. I prefer buying small quantities so I can watch them.

Reply

51 Carol B April 8, 2011 at 2:05 am

I sure hope they were buying some of that just to make the show more exciting, otherwise I feel sorry for the guy that does not like mustard but now has a stockpile of 70 bottles! I like the guy that got all that cereal for a local food pantry, 1100 boxes! That will feed a lot of people. But where did he get 1100 coupons for the cereal?? How much did he pay to get those coupons? Just wondering.
I do coupon and get a lot of stuff for free or 70-90% off, mostly toiletries, cleaners and such. I keep a modest stockpile on hand and donate the rest to several shelters in my area. I mostly use coupons from my Sunday paper, sometimes I will get a second paper if the deals are good. But how do these people get 100's or 1000's of each coupon??
I am slowy building up a stockpile of food, I hope to have six months on hand soon. I am doing this for a couple of reasons. First is as part of a survival plan, I am not a crazy loon, just decided I could be better prepared. The second reason is the rising cost of goods. We have all seen how oil prices are going up and now food and other goods are beginning to rise in price as the inflation rate rises. I have the room in my home to store some things so buying it at a lower price today is a hedge against inflation. The third reason is that my husband nearly lost his job last year and it was really touch and go for a while. I realized that having a modest store of food would be beneficial for times like these. Lastly, I have two college age sons who don't have the time or desire to coupon. Since we are still paying their expenses, I would rather they get stuff from my stash than pay full price. When they come home for a weekend they stock up on food, toiletries, cleaners etc. for themselves and their room mates.
We eat a lot of fresh fruit, vegetables, meat, dairy etc and very little processed food. I will buy packaged foods for food pantries, since that is what they can store. By getting my cleaners, toiletries, and household items free or cheap allows me to spend more on the fresh food we love to eat.
I guess I agree with most of what has been said here. The people featured in the show were over the top, but if that is what they want to do, so be it. The bottom line for me is that Couponing does not have to be extreme to be fun and cost saving.

Reply

52 Shirley April 8, 2011 at 8:25 am

I keep wondering why they do not have to pay sales tax on any thing. In my state food items are tax free but any thing else is taxed. I feel like most of the rest of the comments. I don't know why any one would want so much of one thing.

Reply

53 Holly April 8, 2011 at 1:01 pm

Wow... I so feel the same way you all do. I have a modest stockpile. I get stuff on sale and I try to use a coupon when that sale is happening. I try to only get enough until the sale happens again. I also give some of that stockpile away to people less fortunate than ourselves. We live on a very modest budget. After being diagnosed with cancer, even the medical bills after insurance is mountainous -- therefore, I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE coupons. I consider myself lucky. I still have a job and have a wonderful husband who loves my couponing addiction. There is so much coupon fraud and was just reading an article by another famous coupon blogger that visualized coupon fraud on that show. GRRRR!! I'm an honest couponer. I only use coupons on those items it states. I don't want people to think that all couponers commit fraud. Fraud is a crime. I'm no criminal. I'm just a mom trying to do what's best for her family; like most of us are. :)

Happy Couponing!!

Reply

54 Janelle April 8, 2011 at 7:33 pm

I want to thank you for bringing me back to reality. I am a stay at home mom on the verge of having to go back to work because health insurance sky rocketed, gas is heading towards $4/gal and the ecomomy has not turned around. I have watched Extreme Couponing in an attempt gain tips. Yet each time I go to the store, I find that my couponing has failed me. I find myself in tears of utter frustration (silly to a degree I know) because I just can't seem to figure this money saving task out.
Reality is, I have young children. I feed them fresh fruits and vegetables and healhy meals. As you stated, these items often are not often featured on the show. Beyond that, living in the Northwest, there are very few opportunities to double coupon as stores around here do not offer this. Doubler coupons come now and again in the newspaper limiting you by dollar amount and quantity.
Also I'm finding that Walmart (only ten minutes away) has generic products that often end up cheaper than the super coupon deals for the name brands combined with the travel expenses to venture out further to seek them at compeditor stores. (Perhaps the downfall to living in a smaller town)
I am still learning and surely can do better with my couponing, but it's nice to know that I am on the right track. Thank you again.

Reply

55 Jim April 9, 2011 at 1:16 am

Well said!!! I'm a house husband with pretty much a grown family,so alot of the couponing deals don't work for us.Also we live on the coast in a small town. To get the deals we must drive 70 miles to the "big city". We make our trips count and do take advantage of stocking up on the products we regularly use. I also take advantage of mail order. My wife has a wheat alergy so alot of the pasta and cake mixes don't work for us!

Reply

56 crystal April 9, 2011 at 6:08 pm

the stores where i live wont double anything over $0.50 and have a limit of 3 like coupons being used in a shopping trip. these ladies have stacks of the same coupon would they still hoard items if they had to go 10 or more times to store more stores should have these guidelines to avoid people from buying everything so others cant get it

Reply

57 Rachell April 10, 2011 at 9:05 am

I watched the show and was flabbergasted! Where were all the cranky cashiers and beeps? I will not be watching it again.
I have been couponing for a few years now and I do get some items free but have never purchased items in those quantities. I have given coupons to fellow shoppers, esp if I see see something in their cart that I have a coupon for & I know I won't use it. "Sharing the love" :)
I don't understand how the show is able to promote Extreme Couponing as reality TV? Looks more like a shopping addiction to me.

Reply

58 TRINA April 11, 2011 at 12:38 am

I totally agree with you. I think this show will greatly affect the way "Normal" coupon shoppers are able to shop in the future.This show is totally unrealistic to me. I'm with Rachell where is the cranky eye rolling cashiers? Why isn't the cash register beeping and the cashier digging back through the bag to make sure you have purchased the correct product and quantity? Also I saw one family purchased meat but only paid $5.00 for one order and 39.00 for the other. Where is the meat coupons coming from? I have had store coupons for meat but never in my 12 years of using coupons have I ever seen any where you can get packages of steak for free. This show to me was very disrespectful to the stores policy and also to your fellow shoppers. It's awesome to get great deals but let others take part in this as well. Be a courteous shopper don't clear the shelf. Do you really need 70 bottles mustard and still take 3 to 4 shopping trips a week? Unless you are shopping for a food bank or homeless shelter I say take enough for the month and keep it moving.

Reply

59 Michelle May 4, 2011 at 5:40 am

I believe she was getting the meat for free because she had overage from another item to cover it. (Probably an item she won't even use! LOL)

Reply

60 kim April 11, 2011 at 12:40 pm

I do coupons. And do enjoy getting the discounts and the occasional free items,,, but I think some of this has gotten out of hand. If someone is getting coupons legitimately, ok,,, but I think many are being taken from others, who do want them! or manufactured. I live in a rural area and the coupons are placed in the add bag on the mail box by the road. You used to be able to get yours, and maybe your neighbors, for they didn’t want them. But now, someone goes down the road after they have been hung out and takes them off all the mailboxes. Is this thievery? Or hoggery ? And if that woman on that extreme show has 2200 coupon inserts, where did she get them? Are people not distributing them as they are to be? the person who delivers the bag or the newspapers does not place the coupons in as they are supposed to and keeps them for themselves? Again, thievery or hoggery ? I get so frustrated that this has gone from just saving some money in the grocery store, to a frenzy business. The extremers “rob” the store shelves from everyone else. Ya know, I would like some toilet paper too, but it is gone, all over town. Now that is HOGGERY ! I would like some box stuffing too, but it was gone, in the ten stores I went to between my place of work and home. What if the little guy working all week and just wants to save a little money on the weekly grocery bill? I can’t compete. I guess I will have to buy my coupons off of E-Bay. And that is a whole other discussion. The stores are changing policies, now. I have had several situations in the last week that have changed and affected my couponing. As I said in a reply here, the local Wal-Mart does not redeem free coupons anymore. And they are stricter now on the redeeming of coupons in general. I just had the cashier take off what they wouldn’t comply on and went to Meijer, no problem there. But it is embarrassing to me and makes me look like someone frauding coupons. Holds up the line and frustrates everyone. This is all getting really bad. Remember when a coupon could be used on any item as long as it was that brand, and it had “ no expiration” as the expiration date? Yeah, things of the past. I predict that in five years, or less, there will be no more couponing. The bad apples will have ruined it for all. Stores will go to accepting electronic coupons only, if any at all. Kroger has forwarded with this idea, and that limits one coupon per shopper card, one shopper card per order, or cell phone number like Meijer is doing. There will be no back button print twice coupons, or 2200 coupon inserts. This extreme couponing show only will bring about change sooner than later. That show is making a mockery out of what the majority of the public is doing, and by showing the extremists will only bring changes in many policies governing coupon usage about quicker. CRAZY!

Reply

61 Tina April 11, 2011 at 1:58 pm

I watched an episode of the show and got really upset at the mentality of the shoppers. They are really pretty selfish overall. It made me angry to see them go in and "wipe out" the shelf and just laugh about it. I have been on the receiving end of that many, many times as I am sure many of you have. That leaves no product for anyone else to buy. There are so many of us out here trying to use coupons to stretch our budgets and when we get to the stores, there is nothing left! Also, who could possibly eat all that food that they have hoarded? It's just going to go bad and get thrown out. What a waste! AT LEAST donate it to a food bank! I really think that these extreme couponers have a mental problem (not to be mean, I am serious) and they have hoarding problems and need some help. I don't want people to associate me with them.

Reply

62 Nancy April 12, 2011 at 12:33 am

I agree with all of you. The one lady said she had a 40 year supply of toilet paper, really who needs all of that. There are sales everyday and for someone to Extreme coupon, or should I say Hoard these items is really insane. My time is much better used by shopping for what I need when I need it, but also couponing to save some money. If there are coupons I for a product I need I will buy a couple of news papers to get the coupons I can use.
I watched the Extreme couponing show and I see the lengths people go to to be just plain greedy. Running out at night just so she can get the deals, guess she thinks she is getting a good deal. What about the cost of gas for the car, doesn't that kind of defeat the purpose of going refunding when you make so many trips?
I like your common sense approach to couponing.

Reply

63 Jenny April 19, 2011 at 2:14 pm

I just got a chance to see this new show and I was total shocked with how much of a stockpile that everyone had. I was impressed that the guy did his couponing for care packages for the military, but the other ones that I saw like the one that had her stockpile in her daughters closet or under there beds where a bit extreme which I guess is why they call the show extreme couponing, but spending 5 hours in a food store is beyond me. I don't know the rest of you, but I have better ways to spend my time. After I read your article about this show I thought of a passage from the bible which is Luke 12 verse 16 thru 21 and today I received it in an email and it reminded me today that I wanted to leave a comment after finally seeing the show and after seeing it once was plenty for me it did pass the time in the ER when my second son was sick. Well it was just shocking which I said before. I'm with everyone that said that a month or so is perfectly fine for a stock pile. I spoke with my husband about this show and it reminded us of when we use to belong to a club and got a big container of A1 and we had it in our fridge for years and we ended up throwing away most of it what a waste. This bothered me and I can't imagine how much is wasted with their huge stockpiles here's hoping that it doesn't or at least gets donated to someone who can use it.

Reply

64 Jody April 21, 2011 at 2:25 pm

I just watched the show and I have a question. When these people have these huge stockpiles, don't they end up throwing out the foods that expire? Just wondering...

Reply

65 Tara Kuczykowski April 21, 2011 at 2:55 pm

I suspect that it does happen. I'd hope that most people donate it if they see they're getting close on expiration dates and won't be able to use something though.

Reply

66 Amanda April 22, 2011 at 2:02 pm

About the mustard: They cleared the shelf and the husband helping said "I don't even eat mustard" as she piled another armload into the buggy. Geez!
The one helpful thing I've seen was the housewife who planned out a month's worth of meals, buying fresh meats and frozen veggies and freezing them. The worst was the overweight couple that piled all of the butterfingers and crunch bars into the cart from the checkout aisle (over 150) because they were getting them free. Take a few don't take them ALL!
I'd be happy gettin $50 worth of grocceries for $30, these people get $500 for $5!

Reply

67 Amanda April 22, 2011 at 2:06 pm

ps- I also don't understand how these stores have coupon loop holes...
Every coupon I find is generally "Limit one per purchase per customer." or something to that effect.
The only way to benefit is with double coupon days.

Reply

68 katrinka April 22, 2011 at 6:57 pm

I just what to know their thick. The show really is knot helping anyone thought it was going to be a learning shoe

Reply

69 Robin July 5, 2011 at 1:02 pm

I have watched 6 or more of the shows. I see why the show gets people excited about saving money. But there's a limit. I think to save your family money is a good thing, especially to one show -where the husband had lost his job and there was no income for awhile. But, to buy things your family does not need or can not use for several years down the road, in essence, is not saving money for your family NOW. The money could be applied for fresh food and produce that is much needed in American's diets these days. If you don't work, have lots of spare time on your hands, and want to donate to the local food bank, then this MIGHT be o.k.. But this is not the case. Having coupons to save money is nice. Thanks for providing this service for us. I save an average of 75.00-100.00 a month on them, buying things we NEED and use each month, and get a few extra if I can. Hopefully this will not effect our opportunities to get great coupons in the future.

Reply

70 Patty M July 5, 2011 at 6:20 pm

It has definitely affected couponing in our town. I actually catch cashiers that say they scanned a coupon but it never was. I only use about 5 or less coupons a trip so this is very upsetting when the coupon is for $2 or more. I switch check out lanes with anyone with a large binder, list and several "transactions." Web sites even state they will not send you coupons anymore. I started feeling sorry for the grocery stores since their profit margines are slim.

Reply

71 PJ July 8, 2011 at 5:23 pm

The show takes couponing to an outrageous level. I have been using coupons since my thirtysomething kids were little. I usually save about 30-40% & am happy for that. I can't imagine anyone using 93 bags of croutons or 68 bottles of aspirin.( they must get a lot of headaches) Yes they have made it bad for the rest of us. When I want to try something new, the store never has any, because they (& I have seen them do it) take everything on the shelf. However, the percentage of "extreme" is far less than one would think & the stores do get a fee for each coupon they redeem, so they don't really lose out. I say just lower the prices...

Reply

72 BargainHound July 11, 2011 at 12:10 am

I sooo agree with you! I posted an article very similar to this. TLC has ruined couponing for the rest of us!

http://bargainhound.blogspot.com/2011/06/tlcs-extreme-couponing-show-and-why-i.html

Reply

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>


Previous post:

Next post: